Best 9 Auto Repair Shops Near near Me in Carthage, IL (Update 2025)

Charles Walker 4 stars because pomps raised prices too much when they took over menns. The staff is amazing, though! They do great work. Just too high of prices for a small town. They charge big city prices!

Kelly Davison Family owned business. Theyre very nice and extremely helpful here. Very fair prices and theyre quick. Will continue to do business with them and will be recommending them to our family, friends or anyone we hear looking .

Jodi Jorgensen Very friendly and helpful!! We were traveling through and our boat trailer tire blew out. We looked up nearest tire place and was directed to Menns Firestone. They were so helpful, they had the tire we needed for the trailer and even drove out to fix it themselves. We are so appreciative of their kindness!! They deserve a Five star rating!!

Velora Tisdale I would like to edit my review and tell everyone that the problem we had with Carson’s is resolved a very kind manager reached out and let us know that the problems were just a cause of miscommunication. I appreciate they’re efforts on reaching out and helping resolve this issue.

Madelyn Doran I can’t say enough good things about Carson Motors. They are all super friendly and have very reasonable rates. They do a very good job with explaining how they fix their vehicles and I will only go here to service my car.

Ladawna Royer Chad was a great! He took time to explain the buying process to my teenage son. He explained interest rates and how they impact the overall cost of the vehicle. He was interested in helping us achieve our business goals. Wonderful buying experience!

Clark Irwin Great place. The bill was exactly what they said it would be, done exactly when they said it would be done. Great work!

Jole Londrie Great quality work would definitely recommend!!

David Fox Very high quality work by experienced professionals!

Doug Markussen Towed my car after I hit a deer outside of town. It was early evening and I am from out of town and they made sure I had a safe place to be while I waited for a ride. Thanks guys.

Sheila Shearer Very nice young man unlocked my car in which I had left the keys. Prompt, very reasonable. I am from out of town and was grateful for the help.

Katie Colwell Highway robbery! Refused to let me clean out my car without sheriffs help. Manager is a joke who likes to belittle women, but didnt speak down to my husband. They stole things out of my car. All they want to do is play games!!! Avoid at all cost! Do not do busses with any of Dave fecht businesses or employees!

Jennifer McDonald Great place! Super helpful & kind. We had a check engine light pop up & he directed us to get the right help. I highly recommend them!

Brandon Motley I was traveling through Carthage, IL heading to Chicago and I needed a tire change immediately. I called J&R and was told, that wouldnt be a problem. The employees at J&R go above and beyond when it comes to customer service! From one small business owner to another, it was great to see the care and passion your employees have! Thank you very much for your service I will return!

Andrew Eagan Chris, Jeff, and the whole crew provide hometown service at its very finest. Prices are fair, and they always make an effort to work you in as quickly as possible. Thank you for all that you do!

Boo Boo Good service prompt delivery, thanks KC!