Carmen’s Cafe - Herrin (IL)

5 /5 Amanda Callaway: So much more than desserts and ice cream! They have a full menu of delicious entrees. The staff was absolutely over the top friendly. We were greeted with smiles and excellent service!

3 /5 Dana Hand: The food was decent but the service was terrible. There were four of us and the last meal came out after the other three were almost finished. One order was a frappe and it came out with the fourth meal. Way too expensive for the quality of service and food.

2 /5 Kayla Vaughn: Well I’ve been here a total of 3x- I bought the same fish platter, I love fish The first time was amazing! (Picture to show) The second time I went back was last Sunday, I also brought my aunt and little cousin from a nearby town and the service wasn’t the same. After spending $30 on food, I was still charged for pickles by the server (the first time they just put pickle on the sides) which I didn’t mind, but it was like 3 pickles in the container. I came back today 3/29/25 before my work shift called my order in and the fish was dry and it was not even good at all. The dish was smaller than the first. Idk maybe I should try something else, but it’s definitely not consistent service at all.

5 /5 Samantha Dennis: Absolutely love this place. The staff is super friendly. It is always clean. Their burgers are heavenly. Doesnt matter with one you choose they are all wonderful.