5 /5 Lisa McCluskey: If you want true, homemade Midwestern comfort food, head to the Elm Street Cafe. I had a streaming bowl of chicken and noodles, which was made with homemade noodles and large pieces of shredded chicken. Very flavorful. The side was Cole slaw, which was slightly heavy on the mayo but had a great taste. My brother ordered the catfish and it arrived crispy and steamy hot and he said it was very good. The entrees with two sides was $12.95. Service was delightful. Definitely will go again.

