Firefly Grill - Effingham (IL)

5 /5 Susanne Gonzalez: What a great place to stop for lunch on your travels. Yes its a slight bit of the beaten path but absolutely worth the detour and they have puppy dog food bowls so cute! The only thing I will recommend is to also bring a bowl of water for the pups. But other than that it was amazing the food was absolutely delicious we had the seasonal butternut squash soup and it was absolutely divine, so was the Muffletta and the best Shoshitos we have had in a restaurant. Thank you feel rba wonderful experience!

5 /5 Andrea Szarowicz: Our family recently dined at Firefly Grill, and it was truly an exceptional experience. Visiting from New York, Boston, and Florida, we chose this restaurant based on its strong reputation — and it exceeded our expectations. Our group sampled a wide variety of dishes, including the meatballs, chicken ramen, bao buns, caprese salad, and a 4oz filet, along with family-style sides of risotto, polenta, Brussels sprouts, and seasonal vegetables. Each dish was beautifully presented, expertly prepared, and absolutely delicious. The quality and flavor of every item reflected a thoughtful and creative approach to the menu. Our server was warm, attentive, and made us feel genuinely welcomed, adding to the overall charm of the evening. The only minor drawback was the pacing of service — some dishes arrived several minutes apart, leaving a few of our party waiting while others had already received their meals. That said, the overall experience was outstanding, and we look forward to returning. Firefly Grill is a true gem, and we highly recommend it to anyone seeking a memorable dining experience.

5 /5 Tim Carry: This was a stop on our way back to VT last night. A true farm to table restaurant. Salads were outstanding, fresh and vibrant with local ingredients. I had the banger and mash, she had she had the fried chicken. Delicious. Cocktails get a high mark with an excellent selection of bourbons and real italian cherries in the old fashion. Service, pace, ambiance great. Highly recommend.

5 /5 Chasity Allen: Firefly Grill Farm & Table is an absolute GEM! What sets this place apart is its commitment to freshness and sustainability—60% of the menu is sourced directly from their on-site farm, and the rest comes from local vendors. You can truly taste the difference. I started with the warm Bavarian pretzel bread paired with a rich beer cheese dip—comfort food at its finest. For lunch, the steak tacos with truffle fries were spot-on. Flavorful, satisfying, and beautifully presented. Nicole and Trapper lead an outstanding team that delivers not just great food, but also top-notch service in a fun, welcoming atmosphere. The music is upbeat and lively without being overpowering, adding to the overall vibe. Evie was my server and she was fantastic—knowledgeable, efficient, and genuinely friendly. She made the experience even better. Firefly Grill is now a must-stop for me whenever I’m passing through Effingham, and I’m already recommending it to friends and family. 10/10—highly recommend!

5 /5 Rita Loeding: 5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ - outstanding dining experience. 5 star all around- service attentive and courteous, food delicious and pleasant to the palate, nice variety in the menu- we had hummus board, butternut squash soup and salad, Sea bass, ahi tuna, salmon, and dessert to finish a fabulous dinner. Firefly bread pudding, strawberry rhubarb sorbet. Fresh, fresh, delicious. The atmosphere is relaxing and enjoyable. Full bar available and wine list.