The Porterhouse Steakhouse - Decatur (IL)

5 /5 Lyn Newingham: We came for an early dinner after all of the raving reviews about this place. Was not disappointed. Full service bar, multiple menu options and great deals. We each got a steak of course. It was easily one of the best I’ve had. So juicy and flavorful and not an ounce of fat, cooked perfectly. I also had the twice baked potato and asparagus, both wonderful. Fresh bread (I think it was sourdough), fresh salads, and fresh steak. Highly recommend! Still came away with a box. Perfect local haunt for a great date night or special occasion.

4 /5 S R: Great place to eat for life events! Clean and homey feeling. Had the sirloin and shrimp and enjoyed it! The twice baked potatoes are very good too! Get a reservation to skip the wait!

4 /5 Jason McGuire: The bread is amazing! Had the ribeye with fries and side salad. The steak was well seasoned but just a tad too much pepper. Edit: I came back on a Friday night for their Prime Rib special. It wasnt the prettiest cut but was very tender and had a delicious herb crust.

4 /5 Kris B: We made reservations for our anniversary dinner, and they sat us immediately when we arrived. They were understaffed so service was a little slow. They seemed very nice and to be trying very hard. Our waitress was friendly and apologetic about the slowness. On a positive note, we felt like we got a lot of food for the money. I was afraid to try the steak after reading reviews, and my wifes coworker was there and told my wife her steak tasted "off". I didnt want to overpay for a mediocre steak. As many other reviewers stated, the twice baked potatoes were NOT twice baked potatoes. They were regular potatoes halves and baked with cheese and bacon. My wife had the lobster ravioli and I had the fettuccine Alfredo with steak. The steak part was good, but it was very bland tasting, and I had to add a lot of salt. The lobster ravioli was mediocre. They gave us a free cheesecake that was yummy for our anniversary. With tax, our bill was only $46, so we got a lot of food for our money. We may try it again sometime, but we still will not get the steak there.