illinois Date: 08-31-2025

17 Best Insurance Services in Wheaton, IL

AgentcyAddress
1Mulcare Insurance Agency: Allstate Insurance1811 N Main St D, Wheaton, IL 60187
2Farmers Insurance - Michael Semprevivo209 W Wesley St, Wheaton, IL 60187
3Fred C. Schmitt & Co. - Agency for Auto-Owners Insurance401 S Carlton Ave # 203, Wheaton, IL 60187
4Tiaa-CrefWheaton Ave, Wheaton, IL 60189
5Mark Prutzman - State Farm Insurance Agent1525 E Roosevelt Rd, Wheaton, IL 60187
6Jon Mock - State Farm Insurance Agent1333 N Main St, Wheaton, IL 60187
7Farmers Insurance - Leonard Buddy Smith209 W Wesley St, Wheaton, IL 60187
8Farmers Insurance - Larry Grippo320 S County Farm Rd, Wheaton, IL 60187
9Barraza & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance213 W Wesley St Suite 102, Wheaton, IL 60187
10Gene Plumlee - State Farm Insurance Agent287 Rice Lake Square, Wheaton, IL 60189
11Mark Lathrop - State Farm Insurance Agent324 S Main St, Wheaton, IL 60187
12Goosehead Insurance - Greg Jones100 W Roosevelt Rd Unit B8-204, Wheaton, IL 60187
13Beacon Insurance Agency Inc.2100 Manchester Rd suite 301, Wheaton, IL 60187
14Lisa Carlson- COUNTRY Financial Agent301 W Roosevelt Rd Ste B, Wheaton, IL 60187
15JAMES MULCARE: Allstate Insurance1811 N Main St D, Wheaton, IL 60187
16Advanced Insurance Partners, Inc.1755 S Naperville Rd # 100, Wheaton, IL 60189
17Small Business Insurance Solutions1907 Gresham Cir, Wheaton, IL 60187

1.Mulcare Insurance Agency: Allstate Insurance

Address: 1811 N Main St D, Wheaton, IL 60187

(320) Clients Are Saying about:

Paul Voswinkel Great to work with Aleta. She set me up with much better coverage (better limits deductibles and umbrella) and significant savings (~17% less than what I was paying before). Process was painless! Definitely recommend you consult with them to find savings and better coverage.
5 /5
Jennifer Meyer We have been with All State for 12 years and love them. Casey Mulcare and Samantha have been great to work with. Just a phone call or email away … always quick to respond and so very knowledge! Thanks for your service
5 /5

2.Farmers Insurance - Michael Semprevivo

Address: 209 W Wesley St, Wheaton, IL 60187

(3) Clients Are Saying about:

Tom V This guy is the real deal. Explained my insurance. Reviewed with me. I feel very safe and very covered. Mike is very honest and will be with hin for a long time. Thanks Mike.
5 /5
phillip david Great insurance company . . .
4 /5

3.Fred C. Schmitt & Co. - Agency for Auto-Owners Insurance

Address: 401 S Carlton Ave # 203, Wheaton, IL 60187

(3) Clients Are Saying about:

Chris I was directed by another office to contact this location then spoke to a man named Gary who was quite rude and hung up on me when asked about a claim for a mutual customer. Not professional at all.
1 /5
donald smiter Good personel
4 /5

4.Tiaa-Cref

Address: Wheaton Ave, Wheaton, IL 60189

(3) Clients Are Saying about:

Sara I’m impressed with how easy this agency made everything. They explained all my options and helped me find a policy that fit my budget. The process was simple and quick and I feel secure knowing I’m covered by them.
5 /5
Irais GT I’m happy with the communication and support I’ve received from this agency. They’ve been there every step of the way ensuring I fully understand my coverage and are quick to answer any questions.
5 /5

5.Mark Prutzman - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 1525 E Roosevelt Rd, Wheaton, IL 60187

(23) Clients Are Saying about:

Dr. Susan Cain Fantastic service and follow-up! Thank you Grant! We are so glad we are covered with you. For those looking — I do highly recommend Grant, Mark and their team.
5 /5
JK Samte I have had auto and home insurance with Mark for 7 years now and they have always provided great service and it is a great value. They are always responsive and very professional.Thanks for your services.
2 /5

6.Jon Mock - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 1333 N Main St, Wheaton, IL 60187

(216) Clients Are Saying about:

karen stebel I cant speak highly enough of all the folks at Jon Mock State Farm Insurance. I needed advice on how to proceed with matters when I was hit by someone with another insurance company. Gabriella provided active help with patience, persistence and obvious concern. She even kept checking in after the other insurance finally got the ball rolling on their end. She is awesome!
5 /5
Brooke Anne Buxton Jon Mock was amazing! Not only did he make availability and time to take my unscheduled call, but he did everything in his power to save me all the money that he could. I’m literally paying HALF of what I was paying at Allstate every month for both car and renters insurance.. for the exact SAME policy coverage! I’m so happy I switched and started with him at State Farm
5 /5

7.Farmers Insurance - Leonard Buddy Smith

Address: 209 W Wesley St, Wheaton, IL 60187

8.Farmers Insurance - Larry Grippo

Address: 320 S County Farm Rd, Wheaton, IL 60187

9.Barraza & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance

Address: 213 W Wesley St Suite 102, Wheaton, IL 60187

(18) Clients Are Saying about:

Natalie Lenart My family and I love Barraza and Associates! The employees are dedicated workers and helped me find exactly what I needed. I got a life insurance policy for the best price I’ve seen in the area. They are very transparent and explained my policy very thoroughly.
5 /5
Sophie Trenholm Excellent staff who go above and beyond to provide their best services for individual situations. After receiving many car insurance quotes, American Family was the cheapest option for me by far. Their various discounts make it possible to get good coverage at a low rate. Thank you American Family!
5 /5

10.Gene Plumlee - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 287 Rice Lake Square, Wheaton, IL 60189

(15) Clients Are Saying about:

Todd Samuel My whole family has Been dealing with Gene plumlee insurance forever. Sharon and Michelle are the absolute best to talk with. Any problem insurance related there always there for me and always leave me happy having them as my agent. If you own a house or car or anything of value, your far better off having state farm behind your back when something happens than any competitor out there. Trust me
5 /5
Erik Zeimetz Great experience working with Gene, Sharon and Michelle. The professionalism, care and attention to my insurance needs has helped me out a lot.
5 /5

11.Mark Lathrop - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 324 S Main St, Wheaton, IL 60187

(13) Clients Are Saying about:

Bryce Sack Mark is a fantastic agent! Im not exaggerating when I say that his response time is the quickest Ive ever seen. No matter the time of day, he replies almost immediately. Not to mention his service is back with the quality and guarantees that State Farm offers. Anyone in the greater Chicago area should reach out to him for your insurance needs!
5 /5
John Garland Mark has been my place for insurance for close to 30 years. I have always found them to be completely understanding of my needs and extremely professional. Just one of the reasons we are happy to also call him a life long friend.
5 /5

12.Goosehead Insurance - Greg Jones

Address: 100 W Roosevelt Rd Unit B8-204, Wheaton, IL 60187

(13) Clients Are Saying about:

Bruce Eiseman Greg, is a Great Agent and we’re Friends also. He’s Always got my Best Interest at heart and does a Great Job handling my Insurance needs.
5 /5
Sean Foley Greg has done a phenomenal job as my insurance agent since we bought our home in 2021. Greg goes the extra mile and looks out for his customers. When my current home and auto insurance company rates jumped quite a bit higher over the course of a year he pivoted us towards another insurance company which was just as good if not better, that had lower rates and offered more. Hes is also a very personal and hard working guy, looking out for your best interests. If youre looking for an insurance agent, Greg is your guy!
5 /5

13.Beacon Insurance Agency Inc.

Address: 2100 Manchester Rd suite 301, Wheaton, IL 60187

(12) Clients Are Saying about:

Integro Builders We have been working with Dawn and the Beacon Insurance team for several years. They are consummate professionals. Responsible, knowledgeable, and proactive. As a business owner, I choose partners who follow up with me, not the other way around. The Beacon team does this exceptionally, they are a huge asset to our firm. They are a pleasure to work with on projects. We highly recommend.
5 /5
Jeff Gelband I worked with Dawn at Beacon Insurance to get a better rate on my business owners policy and workmans comp. She was able to keep the same coverage I had, but save me about 30% on my premiums. Dawn was a pleasure to work with and got our policy setup quickly. If you are looking for lower rates on your insurance, I highly recommend giving them a call.
5 /5

14.Lisa Carlson- COUNTRY Financial Agent

Address: 301 W Roosevelt Rd Ste B, Wheaton, IL 60187

(1) Clients Are Saying about:

Luis Rodriguez As a first time home owner I knew nothing of this home owners insurance untill recently when after 8 years with this company it was brought to my attention that I was being g take. Advantage of by this agency I called and cancelled my policy as it was about to be up for renewal and they still chose to cash my mortgage company’s check even though I called and canceled their excuse was that I did not tell them the date so they chose to take advantage of me a little more untill this week my mortgage company called to let me know I have two policies on my home and do t bother calling corporate they have drew Kelly call and agree with you on almost everything u tell him just to tell you there’s nothing they can do but take your money on a positive i learned paying over 3k for homeowners insurance is not normal wish I would have brought this up years ago
1 /5

15.JAMES MULCARE: Allstate Insurance

Address: 1811 N Main St D, Wheaton, IL 60187

16.Advanced Insurance Partners, Inc.

Address: 1755 S Naperville Rd # 100, Wheaton, IL 60189

images Advanced Insurance Partners, Inc.

17.Small Business Insurance Solutions

Address: 1907 Gresham Cir, Wheaton, IL 60187