Best 13 Jewelry Stores Near You Peoria, IL

Leah Johnson My husband and I recently upgraded my engagement ring and wedding band, and we couldn’t be happier with our experience at Bremer Jewelry! After visiting all the jewelers in the area, Bremer had the best selection by far—and the most welcoming atmosphere. Their customer service truly stood out from the rest. Dan helped us throughout the entire process and went above and beyond to make sure we found the perfect ring set. He really listened to what I wanted and was so patient through multiple appointments. He took the time to show me similar styles and thoughtful alternatives so we could explore every option. He even encouraged me to come back in one last time—just to be 100% sure—knowing how indecisive I can be. That extra care meant so much. We’re so grateful for Dan and the team at Bremer, and we’ll definitely be back for any future jewelry needs. Highly recommend

Lisa Huston Excellent service and craftsmanship. It may take some time to get your custom work back, but the quality of the work makes it worth it.

Amy Ulrich We love Jones Brothers Jewelers they alway are very accommodating to help us get exactly what we want. They have a great selection of current jewelry to choose from. We love Aly- it feels very personal to have someone you enjoy working with!

Reed Sanders Kevin Kelly Jewelers is by far the best jewelry store in the area. Service there is excellent, with the quality and price on their jewelry are unmatched. I got our engagement ring and wedding bands from there and the experience is a 12/10. Would absolutely recommend and anyone going anywhere else is just doing themselves a disservice but not stopping in to check them out!

Makenzia Jackson Makaylia was very kind & attentive to me. She explained the different options I had. She explained the deals. She completed 4 new piercings on me. She completed 2 cartilage piercings & did my second holes on my lobes. She explained to me how to clean my piercings also. She was very professional & helpful during my experience.

Big Bank I highly recommend these professionals. My watch links looked welded shut. Took it here spent 15 bucks for about 15 mins. Very kind people too may I add. Thank yall so much!

LL Grey The owner is a nice guy! I enjoy his customer service. The products are very quality and you get what you pay for!!

Jim Dempsey 45 years ago, we bought our wedding rings from Rodger. He was just getting started in his business. Recently, my wife lost her diamond when her ring got caught in a fence. She didn’t realize the diamond was missing until the next day. We searched but couldn’t find it. She couldn’t get the ring off her finger and had to have a local jeweler cut it off. My ring was too small as well. We mailed both rings back to Rodger’s son, Nick. We just got them back today and they are absolutely gorgeous! They look brand new! We highly recommend Rodger Burke Jewelers. They have great prices and are very professional. You won’t be disappointed!

Elona Mason Recently got engaged, went into Kay Jewelers and worked with Whitney, to get an idea of what type of ring I wanted, and Whitney, saw my other rings and went right to one that would go perfectly with my current ring style! It was perfect! On the first go around! I fell in love with it! Looking online is different from the store, glad I went into the store instead! I am very pleased... Whitney was a great help! Thank you so much! Go see Whitney for all your needs shes very knowledgeable!

P. Pitcher I havent patronized this place for YEARS after overhearing the female owner talking to her friend/co-worker about how incompetent a customer was - in a BEGINNER jewelry-making class! All while ignoring me and a couple of other customers in the shop. After yet another subsequent poor customer service experience, I never went back...but it led me to a great bead shop in Bloomington which has a friendly and knowledgeable owner. Definitely worth the drive! Glad the grumpy curmudgeons left Junction City. Their snobbish attitude was atypical of business owners in that shopping center anyway so they werent a good fit. Ive since heard of numerous other (now former) customers who had offensive experiences and stopped shopping there as well. Its really too bad because they had beautiful jewelry for purchase and lots of supplies, too. Makes me wonder if they were actually asked to leave the Junction...

Olivia Hall We could not recommend Roger & Hollands enough!!! Angie went above and beyond to design my dream engagement ring, all while getting us the best deal. We will definitely be back in the future!

Sarah Fleischauer A good place to go for positive motivational inspiration, and good laughs and quality jewelry. Wide variety of choices in the jewelry.

Nikki Burk We went to Nature Haven today because my kids have a new love for different types of rocks. The owner was SO helpful and SO informative. He was incredibly sweet with my boys and answered any questions they had. I also feel their prices are incredibly fair. We had a blast! Thank you!!