Pagliais Pizza - Charleston (IL)

5 /5 Carrie Maxwell: I ordered a large mushroom, bacon, sausage & black olive pizza this time & it looks AMAZING!!!. This is Definitely my new go to place for Pizza!!! My order was ready to go in 15 minutes. You can tell that its definitely homemade pizza. Its a little spicy but delicious!!! I would definitely continue to order again. The young men were very careful at watching the cooking pizzas, you can see how they take their jobs very seriously and theyre all very kind too. This is Definitely my new OMGEEE Pizza Place!!!

5 /5 Tasha Zuniga: I have had this stuff since I was a little girl! Definitely found my love for spaghetti at pagliai’s! It was my grandmother favorite place to go every Wednesday night we would get spaghetti and garlic bread along with most Friday nights it was customary to get a large half pep and half sausage pizza:) so many good memories thank to you guys❤️

3 /5 Penny A Thompson: I must we generally love the pizza!! But...my husband recently got a special with hardly any sausage on it which he loves. So he decided to get just a sausage pizza yesterday & it came with about 6 pieces of sausage & a whole bunch of cheese. Needless to say we wont be back for awhile.

5 /5 mr burr: First off let me say weve been coming here for years and will continue to do its always been great! Unfortunately though this time our server dropped the ball and left our pizza sitting on the counter long enough it wasnt hot when it was finally brought out 45 minutes after we ordered it. When we ask her about it she blew it off and said "well theres a stack of carry-out orders ahead of you". Soo when she did bring the cold pizza she didnt bother to bring us any plates then we had to wait for those while she kept repeatedly asking me if we needed red pepper. NO! Bring us plates! But the real kicker was other people were seated long after we were next to us, placed their orders and got their food long before we did I guess she thought we were blind. Hopefully, shes not there next time we are but if this is any indication of her normal routine Im betting shes not. Bottom line is if shed have owned her screw up we would have just let it go and moved on.