illinois Date: 08-31-2025

12 Best Insurance Services in Jacksonville, IL

AgentcyAddress
1Allstate Insurance Agent: Jacksonville, IL Agency901 W Morton Ave Ste 10b, Jacksonville, IL 62650
2reassure america life insurance company1275 Sandusky Rd, Jacksonville, IL 62650
3Phil Wiegand - State Farm Insurance Agent506 W Morton Ave, Jacksonville, IL 62650
4Regan Bruenger - State Farm Insurance Agent275 N Westgate Ave, Jacksonville, IL 62650
5MidState Insurance Agency, Inc.1101 W Morton Ave B, Jacksonville, IL 62650
6Jeff Mossman - State Farm Insurance Agent1103 W Morton Ave, Jacksonville, IL 62650
7Fergurson Insurance1840 S Main St, Jacksonville, IL 62650
8Success Insurance Illinois1217 W Morton Ave, Jacksonville, IL 62650
9THOMAS TIFFIN INSURANCE1840 S Main St, Jacksonville, IL 62650
10Secure Insurance Co.10 E Central Pk Plz, Jacksonville, IL 62650
11Shelter Insurance1835 W Morton Ave, Jacksonville, IL 62650
12Mike Hubbs Insurance & Financial Services501 W State St, Jacksonville, IL 62650

1.Allstate Insurance Agent: Jacksonville, IL Agency

Address: 901 W Morton Ave Ste 10b, Jacksonville, IL 62650

(3) Clients Are Saying about:

Porky Hog lots cheaper than Progressive
4 /5

2.reassure america life insurance company

Address: 1275 Sandusky Rd, Jacksonville, IL 62650

(2) Clients Are Saying about:

Barbara Medieros If I could give less than 1 star I would. My husband had insurance with this company for 20 years and paid faithfully without missing a payment. All of a sudden they started withdrawing $613.87 per month out of the account instead of $61.51 per month. When we realized it after several months we contacted Re-Assure America only to be told they insurance term had expired & that was our new premium. They never contacted us or informed us of any change in the premium or the expiration date of the policy. We never gave authorization for any amount other than the $61.51 to be deducted from our account. They are now refusing to refund the money taken out of our account illegally. I will be contacting the State Regulatory Board and an attorney for compensation.
1 /5

3.Phil Wiegand - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 506 W Morton Ave, Jacksonville, IL 62650

(18) Clients Are Saying about:

Laurie Nyberg Due to unforeseen circumstances I had to be dropped from my State Farm policy. Which was fairly upsetting because I had been w customer with State Farm for a long time. But I was dropped from my home owners policy which was out of the agents control completely. This was quite upsetting but the agent did reach out to me and did his best to make sure the transom was as smooth as possible. I realize now he was just doing everything in his control to make the situation as smooth as possible even though he’s not in control as to who and when the customer may get dropped from their policy.
5 /5
Heidi Young Had a small fender bender after hours on a Friday. We were able to reach the office, confirmed deductible and next steps and we were in our way with an estimate for repairs. Jeni was professional, responsive and quick to answer all our questions! In a world where customer service often takes a back seat, State Farm knocked it out of the park!
5 /5

4.Regan Bruenger - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 275 N Westgate Ave, Jacksonville, IL 62650

(18) Clients Are Saying about:

Declan Flynn This State Farm location has been great to work with. Their agents are friendly, professional, and always quick to respond. They made it easy to understand my coverage and helped tailor a policy that fit my needs. The claims process was smooth and stress-free. Highly recommend for reliable service and peace of mind.
5 /5
Blake Shoufler From the moment I signed up, their customer service has been outstanding—friendly, knowledgeable, and always willing to go the extra mile to help. Anytime I’ve had questions about my policy or needed assistance, I was able to get clear, prompt answers. When I had to file a claim, the process was fast, straightforward, and stress-free. My agent kept me informed every step of the way, and the payout was handled quickly and fairly. It’s such a relief to have an insurance company that actually delivers on its promises.
5 /5

5.MidState Insurance Agency, Inc.

Address: 1101 W Morton Ave B, Jacksonville, IL 62650

(17) Clients Are Saying about:

Jacob Shelby I’ve used Seth at midstate for a couple years now and have been beyond pleased with his services, time, and prices. Seth goes out of his way to make sure his customers have what they need no matter the time or day. I recommend everyone gives him a shot, I can guarantee Seth at Midstate will not disappoint.
5 /5
Mike Rohn My Camper Awning got tore off in a wind n rain storm.I called my agent Seth Roig and he got right on it.!!!I recommend him to everyone.And I recommend Midstate Insurance!!!
5 /5

6.Jeff Mossman - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 1103 W Morton Ave, Jacksonville, IL 62650

(147) Clients Are Saying about:

Debbie Jones Jeff Mossman has been my insurance agent since I relocated to Jacksonville Illinois in 2016. His office has always been very friendly, helpful and professional whenever I called or visited the office personally. Ive had several vehicle claims because of deer and raccoon damages and the claims were taken care of immediately as far as rentals and helping me find the best collision shops in Jacksonville. I would recommend Jeff Mossman -State Farm Insurance Agent to anyone who wants a honest dependable and trustworthy insurance agent.
5 /5
Amanda Fox Jeff Mossman and his office staff are by far the very best you will ever work with! They are quick to respond to any questions and got us the best rates on home and auto insurance! I highly recommend checking them out today!
5 /5

7.Fergurson Insurance

Address: 1840 S Main St, Jacksonville, IL 62650

images Fergurson Insurance

(11) Clients Are Saying about:

randy hull Being on a fixed income makes buying insurance a very hard burden, prices are going up quicker than popcorn pops. The fine people at Fergurson Insurance Agency made that burden a lot easier for me. They helped me to understand the coverage for both my truck and home, was very helpful in taken the time to answer all my questions, Oh yes, they also saved me a bundle of money. Thank you Fergurson insurance Randy W. Hull
5 /5
Leigh Ann Burnett The staff are so very friendly and happy to help you!! Ànd they know there customers by name.
5 /5

8.Success Insurance Illinois

Address: 1217 W Morton Ave, Jacksonville, IL 62650

(1) Clients Are Saying about:

Jill Miller Awesome, professsional
5 /5

9.THOMAS TIFFIN INSURANCE

Address: 1840 S Main St, Jacksonville, IL 62650

10.Secure Insurance Co.

Address: 10 E Central Pk Plz, Jacksonville, IL 62650

11.Shelter Insurance

Address: 1835 W Morton Ave, Jacksonville, IL 62650

12.Mike Hubbs Insurance & Financial Services

Address: 501 W State St, Jacksonville, IL 62650