illinois Date: 08-31-2025

19 Best Insurance Services in Belleville, IL

AgentcyAddress
1Dave Threlkeld - State Farm Insurance Agent1095 N Green Mt Rd #100, Belleville, IL 62221
2Farmers Insurance - Crystal Gonzenbach3704 N Belt W, Belleville, IL 62226
3Jones Insurance Agency1624 Carlyle Ave #515, Belleville, IL 62221
4Adam Peters - COUNTRY Financial Representative3501 N Belt W, Belleville, IL 62226
5Pufalt-Pauley Insurance Agency315 N Illinois St, Belleville, IL 62220
6Don Forhan: Allstate Insurance6909 W Main St, Belleville, IL 62223
7Kate Elder - State Farm Insurance Agent1638 Carlyle Ave, Belleville, IL 62221
8Schickedanz Insurance Agency300 W Main St #1, Belleville, IL 62220
9Shelter Insurance - Bob Madewell204 W Main St, Belleville, IL 62220
10Protection Direct505 Corporate Ctr Dr, Belleville, IL 62221
11Steve Knapp - State Farm Insurance Agent5200 W Main St, Belleville, IL 62226
12Gasaway Insurance Agency4717 W Main St, Belleville, IL 62226
13Schmale Insurance Inc305 Carlyle Ave ste a, Belleville, IL 62221
14Jody White - State Farm Insurance Agent15 Bronze Pointe N B, Belleville, IL 62226
15Yaekel & Associates Insurance Services Inc1915 W Main St, Belleville, IL 62226
16Katherine Frazier - State Farm Insurance Agent1600 Lebanon Ave #103, Belleville, IL 62221
17Steck-Cooper & Co.2810 Frank Scott Pkwy W #804, Belleville, IL 62223
18Harnist Insurance Agency Inc700 E Main St, Belleville, IL 62220
19Dave Barnes Insurance ServicesBelleville, IL 62221

1.Dave Threlkeld - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 1095 N Green Mt Rd #100, Belleville, IL 62221

(47) Clients Are Saying about:

Darin Morton i am in the same industry as Dave... recently he helped me with something so trivial, but it took much of his time, and he did it so selflessly!!! i am SO appreciative. If he does this for me, many states away, i would say he does a tremendous job for his local customers. easy choice to have your insurance with his office!! thank you Dave!!
5 /5
linda koenig I have worked with Brittany today and she is fabulous at her job. She is always available and takes the time in answering my questions. I have been with Dave and his father before him for almost 60 years. Wouldn’t ever think of changing.
5 /5

2.Farmers Insurance - Crystal Gonzenbach

Address: 3704 N Belt W, Belleville, IL 62226

(4) Clients Are Saying about:

Tracy Knowles Great agent! Very knowledgeable, helpful and accomadating. Competitive rates paired with excellent service. Glad to have her as our agent!
5 /5

3.Jones Insurance Agency

Address: 1624 Carlyle Ave #515, Belleville, IL 62221

(4) Clients Are Saying about:

Kerri Peters Jason was very helpful, I had an agent that was not responding to my calls or emails so I contacted Jason to run some rates within 2 days I had quotes and everything I needed to switch over along with information on how to cancel my current policies Thank you for your help and for taking care of everything so quickly
5 /5
Brandy Fletcher Mr. Jones is Honest, hard Working, trustworthy, cares about his clients, dependable, and available when you need him!! Highly recommend!
5 /5

4.Adam Peters - COUNTRY Financial Representative

Address: 3501 N Belt W, Belleville, IL 62226

(36) Clients Are Saying about:

Sonny Salah Adam is the best! He’s the most helpful, and honest, person that I’ve ever worked with. He makes the stress of insurance, so much easier and makes everything easy and smooth. He will always go above and beyond for his clients
5 /5
Abby Carlson Adam has been our insurance agent for over 10 years. His office is easy to get in contact with, thanks to his assistant Debbie who is amazing. Adam is incredibly knowledgeable and realistic. He takes his time explaining any and all options you have, but does not try to push you towards any for his own personal gain. My husband and I have all of our insurance and many investments such as retirement through Adam. Country Financial is easy to work with on claims and walks you through the entire process. You are assigned to one person who handles your entire claim, which makes the process so much less stressful! HIGHLY recommend Adam Peters and his team!!
5 /5

5.Pufalt-Pauley Insurance Agency

Address: 315 N Illinois St, Belleville, IL 62220

(33) Clients Are Saying about:

Marcy Morris I am so grateful to have found Julie, and I love being able to work with her! I know she is looking out for the best deals and has my best interest in mind. She found a great deal for me on my car insurance, and she even helped me when I moved out of state! I know I can always count on her! Would definitely recommend to everyone!
5 /5
Krissy Basinger I just love working with Becky. She is very quick to respond to all my needs and was able to get me a price point that blew the other companies away. You wont regret making a switch.
5 /5

6.Don Forhan: Allstate Insurance

Address: 6909 W Main St, Belleville, IL 62223

(29) Clients Are Saying about:

Kathy Frazier The absolute BEST agent! Keeps me informed and responds so quickly to any problems or concerns I have!
5 /5
Betty Bauers I am very bias towards Allstate, mainly thru Don Forhans office. I have been with Don since I was 17...now 72. Have no complaints what so ever. My parents were with Forhans office for over 67 years ...it was my parents who got me to Forhans...wouldnt think of switching agents or ins. co.
4 /5

7.Kate Elder - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 1638 Carlyle Ave, Belleville, IL 62221

(271) Clients Are Saying about:

Sheila Mccarver Kate is an amazing insurance agent she takes the time to walk you through your insurance policy step by step and makes recommendations if needed. She explained how the recommended coverage would benefit my coverage whether it was with my home or auto coverage. Kate has been our agent since 1999, couldn’t ask for a better agent
5 /5
JoEllen Potchen-Webb We recently changed insurance to Kate Elder State Farm because we had moved and wanted an agent closer to our new home. They have been extremely helpful in getting our account moved over and in making the changes we needed to our policies. When we went in for a review of our policies they took time to answer all of our questions and help us look at a variety of options. I recommend this agency.
5 /5

8.Schickedanz Insurance Agency

Address: 300 W Main St #1, Belleville, IL 62220

(2) Clients Are Saying about:

Richard Sauget III Amazing Service! Dave is such an amazing guy to work with, I couldnt imagine doing my insurance with anyone else.
5 /5

9.Shelter Insurance - Bob Madewell

Address: 204 W Main St, Belleville, IL 62220

(2) Clients Are Saying about:

Tramon Hardy I like the insurance
3 /5

10.Protection Direct

Address: 505 Corporate Ctr Dr, Belleville, IL 62221

(172) Clients Are Saying about:

Nia Jones I had an excellent experience with Home Protection Direct, thanks to Lauren and Cameron! They made enrolling my mother in a home warranty incredibly smooth and stress-free. From the start, they were knowledgeable, patient, and professional, taking the time to explain all the coverage options in detail. They answered every question we had with clarity and ensured we felt confident in our decision. Kudos to you!
5 /5
Destiny I’ve called this company 6 to 8 times over the last 6 months to be removed from their mailing list. I’ve been assured I’ve been removed each time and yet the letters keep coming every month. BUYER BEWARE. This company is NOT accredited through the Better Business Bureau. They send aggressive letters in order to scare people into purchasing their services. Find an accredited business that does not try to bully you into purchasing their services. You’ll have no recourse with this company in the likely event their services will fail you. (Check out the reviews from people they’ve screwed.)
1 /5

11.Steve Knapp - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 5200 W Main St, Belleville, IL 62226

images Steve Knapp - State Farm Insurance Agent

(17) Clients Are Saying about:

Bianca Jenkins If I could give this man negative 5 stars I would. He started yelling at me and berating me because I didn’t have the correct information at the time of purchasing my rental insurance agreement. He has a very short temper and needs anger management. I tried to talk to him and give him the information needed and he refused because he was frustrated about the situation. I didnt what the apartment asked me to and called him to correct what was wrong. If you hate your job then don’t be an insurance agent.
1 /5
Ruby Austell Mr. Knapp is knowledgeable, courteous, professional and a valuable asset to The State Farm Insurance Agency. I have known and been a customer for more than fifty years. Because of the reputable and good service I receive ; I have increased my coverage with him (car, home and life). I am very pleased with the service I receive. I will continue to patronize him. I tell others about him. I value him and his services, If you want Good Service Call Mr. Knapp!
5 /5

12.Gasaway Insurance Agency

Address: 4717 W Main St, Belleville, IL 62226

(16) Clients Are Saying about:

Elizabbeth Kotras Customer service is outstanding! Super friendly and eager to help! They are ready to answer any questions you may have regarding changing insurance companies or when filing a claim. Glad, I have someone I can trust and depend on when it comes to insurance companies. Recommend, them to everyone out there.
5 /5
JAZMIN Perez Excellent experience from start to finish. Isabel was courteous and quick. She handled the pay out for my car and I am impressed with the service
5 /5

13.Schmale Insurance Inc

Address: 305 Carlyle Ave ste a, Belleville, IL 62221

images Schmale Insurance Inc

(16) Clients Are Saying about:

Michael Richardson They were great to work with for 2 years. Got married and attempted to work with them to combine car insurance, move our home owners, open a business policy with them, and they talked me into keeping my renters policy simply becuase the engagement ring was covered under that. I agreed thinking it would be a easy way to save some time and they would have everythign quoted and executed in a few weeks. Not counting the business policy, we were looking for roughly over a million in coverages. 12+ weeks go by and they could never even get me a quote. Multiple calls and it was apparent that they had not even looked at any of the information that I sent over to them. Tried to call again today, was on hold for 10 minutes, got disconnected, no call back, I called them back after waiting for a few, got put on hold again. No apologies, no reasoning, just "Okay" when I stated that I want to cancel everything that I currently have with them. It appears that they have enough business that they do not value the opportunity to provide existing customers growth and added policies.
1 /5
Chad Hunt Ive been a customer with Schmale Insurance for nearly 10 years and they have been excellent to work with. The office does a great job of handling every request with thoroughness and efficiency. The agents have done a great job of individualizing my insurance options to fit my every need. I highly recommend working with the Schmale group. Stephen Sedlak has done a great job of making insurance something I no longer have to worry about.
5 /5

14.Jody White - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 15 Bronze Pointe N B, Belleville, IL 62226

(143) Clients Are Saying about:

sunny daze I spoke with Anthony and the Collinsville office this morning. He went over all the options available to me to give me the best quote available I was very satisfied with the information Ive got and Im happy to say I am now doing business with Allstate. Thank you Anthony for the great service.
5 /5
Betsy Burge Anthony from Jody’s office has been quick to help me save money on both my auto and home insurance. He was great in explaining the different options for coverage. He made it quick and easy in making the transition from another insurance company. Great customer service!!
5 /5

15.Yaekel & Associates Insurance Services Inc

Address: 1915 W Main St, Belleville, IL 62226

(129) Clients Are Saying about:

Genelle Davis Josie was just wonderful!!!! She was consistent with communication, very pleasant & courteous. She was able to secure me with a really great auto insurance rate & had me covered in no time. I really appreciate her time, patience, & professionalism.
5 /5
Lisa Bujnak I found Yaekel & Assoc. when googling Erie Insurance. I have had my home & car insurance with them ever since. I would give them 10 stars if I could. A person answers the phone, no automated voice. They go over my policies before renewal to see if there are any changes that could save me some money. If I call with questions they are answered quickly. Good customer service is something that is getting harder to find. I appreciate their attention to detail and honesty. Erie insurance doesnt advertise, if you are looking for excellent insurance give Yaekel a call. They had quotes for me in less than 24 hours. I have been with them for years. Excellent local insurance office!
5 /5

16.Katherine Frazier - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 1600 Lebanon Ave #103, Belleville, IL 62221

(11) Clients Are Saying about:

Tasha Jones Service from Katherine and Sue was great. State Farm overall has become a waste of money. Anytime you use your coverage, the premiums increase. I only filed 1 claim for hail damage. I moved to TX and had to switch offices and the premium went up 30 more dollars. I have been with State Farm for years. This is insane. I was able to get the same coverage thru Progressive for close to the same amount I was paying in IL.
4 /5
Austin S If you want to get jerked around for a few months with a hole in your roof go with State Farm! Despicable company. Cant wait to leave!
1 /5

17.Steck-Cooper & Co.

Address: 2810 Frank Scott Pkwy W #804, Belleville, IL 62223

(11) Clients Are Saying about:

Mark LeVeck I find Steck Cooper and company to be the independent agency that I wished I had had all of my adult life. These folks are professional, personable, competent and caring. I also like that they are local and I feel comfortable stepping in or calling anytime I have questions and speak to a real life person. Thanks for all you do!
5 /5
ron hughes Appreciate the great customer service!! N quick response time!! N ease at which my whole experience was!!! N that there rates are amazing!!! After being canceled by previous insurance company!! For 2 claims!!! Were only company that didnt wanna gouge me and quote just ridiculous high rates!!! Thanks again!!!
5 /5

18.Harnist Insurance Agency Inc

Address: 700 E Main St, Belleville, IL 62220

(11) Clients Are Saying about:

Lisa Matter Having worked in the insurance industry in the past, I value the professionalism and knowledge that Joe Harnist provides as our insurance agent. It wasnt about saving money for us, it was about customer service but in the end we gained BOTH! Joe goes above and beyond to ensure your insurance needs are covered and there are NO GAPS. Make the call today......you will be happy you did! Thank you Joe for piece of mind and the extra savings you have provided to me and my family.
5 /5
Seth Maul My family has used Harnist for as long as I can remember. Joe Sr. and Joe Jr. have given us beyond exceptional service. They are always responsive, are generous with their time and advice, and truly have our best interests at heart. They recently saved us several hundred dollars on our home owners and auto policies without us even asking for them to check or knowing until the statement came. Recommend them to everyone I know. You won’t be disappointed.
5 /5

19.Dave Barnes Insurance Services

Address: Belleville, IL 62221