Caseys - Olney (IL)

2 /5 Bruce S: Pizza - Ordered a specialty pizza online at 7:15 PM on a weekday, app said it would ready at 7:45. Went to pick up at 7:45 and worker said they were just starting to make it. Went back after 20 minutes and worker said they were just putting it in oven. Finally picked up at 8:15. I dont care if it takes an hour and they are busy, just tell me it will be an hour and quit making up earlier times for pick up. Pizza was good but walking into the store 3 times to pick it up does not please me and hence 2 star review.

1 /5 Hunter Beaudin: Update, food was not cooked correctly, toppings are wrong, this caseys is absolutely the worst caseys Ive every ordered from! Ordered food off door dash, was made aware that the food wouldnt be ready for more than half an hour after ny delivery person got to the store to pick it up...Ive worked in fast food, and high class restaurants, and this is ridiculous. Im sure my pizza will be messed up by the time I get it as well....

5 /5 Ethann Glinski: Took awhile but was the best supreme pizza Ive had in a long time better than Joes for sure

1 /5 Jacob: Went into the store today at approximately 1pm. All the shipments were still out from the truck unpacked. Theres never any drinks or any cold drinks because the employees I guess refuse to unpack them? It smelled like mildue in the gas station and I brought this to an employees attention. They told me "we dont know sir" I said " well I would at least put some bleach down, no one would wanna eat here smelling that" they said " you dont have to eat here leave sir". Will not be going back!