Gabby Goat American Pub & Grill - Effingham (IL)

5 /5 Jill Lusher: Great place! Our server Jenna was great, friendly, and constantly checking on us. Food amazing. FYI Horseshoe Style burgers are totally shareable. My husband had to take 1/2 of it home. My fish tacos were also very filling. Best meal of our vacation.

5 /5 Greg Jones: First time eating in the new building, I think it might have been the first lunch they were open. The new place is huge and is really nice. It’s a big improvement. Had my “usual” which is a cup of chili and the Carolina Sloppy Joe. They were even better than usual! I know I need to break out of my rut and try something different, maybe someday because it all looks so good! My wife and her sister both got smash burger sliders and enjoyed them. My nephew had a build your own burger and fries. I tried the fries. Crispy, a little greasy and very good. Couldn’t get a picture of the burger, he was half way through it before the waitress finished handing out our good, so I guessed he liked it! Had a great waitress, she checked on us often. My favorite place in Effingham.

5 /5 Harsha V: Everything was perfect in this restaurant. Had some amazing loaded nachos and then you had one of the best burger I could say. We ordered 2 flaming goat burgers but one with chicken and other with impossible meat, they were the best I had to say. Mind you they are hot!! Would definitely visit again if I get a change.

4 /5 Mark Pitts: A great place for a good meal at a fair price. We had lunch here with family and really enjoyed it. The menu is mostly sandwiches and pub style food, but they also have good salads, soups, and appetizers. There are a few options for vegetarians, and they do have Impossible burgers available. Dinner specials are available (after 5 PM) and they have several desserts. Portions were large (especially the Horseshoe sandwich that was more than I could eat!) and all of our choices from the menu were delicious. There is a full bar (of course) and a great beer selection including multiple beers on tap. Service was good, even though the place was very busy. We will definitely return here sometime and will recommend it to others.