5 /5 Kimberly Nelson: Love this place. Been coming to this place for 50 yrs. Back when it was called The Red Mill and it had the horseshoe game in the back of it. With a wheelbarrel table. 3 stars on food pizza lacked flavor. I think it was more the sauce. But I have been there other times and sandwiches are good. You still rate in the top 3 with me in McHenry County.

