Yoders Kitchen - Arthur (IL)

5 /5 Jason McGuire: If you ever find yourself in Illinois Amish Country (or within a couple hours), you have to go to Yoders Kitchen in Arthur, IL. There are too many things to choose from so go for the buffet. Every night there are different items (menu is online) but I waited until tonight so I could get all of my favorite comfort foods: broasted chicken, chicken and noodles, mashed potatoes, green beans (all of those are on the buffet every day for lunch and dinner) plus pot roast, turkey and dressing, and spaghetti. They also have a huge salad bar, a couple different soups, and a few different cobblers and treats for dessert. There are fresh baked pies also but those are an extra charge. Everything is made from scratch and definitely tastes like eating a Sunday dinner at Grandmas. Everything was delicious; there wasnt a single item I didnt like.

5 /5 Hicks-Jones Penny (PJ): It was great absolutely loved it. My husband and I decided its going to be a monthly trip. Its a buffet which there arent a lot of anymore in this area.

3 /5 Dennis Errichiello: Stopped into Yoder’s Kitchen in Arthur, Illinois, for a quick lunch. Place was clean, and they got me seated and my drink order in right away. Can’t complain about the service, it was fast. I went for the buffet, figuring an Amish place would have a good spread. Well, it was alright, but not what I was expecting. The fried chicken was crispy, which is always a plus, and the flavors were decent enough. Though, I have to say, that chicken and noodles needed a good dose of salt. It was just a little bland. It wasn’t a bad meal, but I was hoping for more variety. Left feeling a bit underwhelmed.

5 /5 Angela Salgado Avila Y Familia: It was our first time here , and we really enjoyed the food . Homemade biscuits and Peanut butter was Delish. The waitress friendly and patient. The manager treated us kindly . ❌Just the cashier was rude and not friendly at all , I was ready to pay in line and when it was my turn she yelled at me ma’am ! Move to the register . It was lunch time Se was very frustrated, and I think she didn’t wanted to be there due to her bad attitude.

5 /5 Brandon Gaither: Everyone was so kind, and each item was cooked to perfection. We drove an hour and half just for the buffet and to head home. Worth stopping anytime youre close by..... or a little drive.