Top 14 Rated Jeweler in Chicago, IL (part 2)

Alicia Brill Tammy provided me with an incredibly thoughtful, personalized, and professional experience. I had three inherited pieces that I wanted to transform to match my own style, and after being turned away by several designers, I was overjoyed when Tammy not only accepted the project but also approached it with the same passion and care that I had. Over the course of several months, we collaborated on multiple drawings and revisions, holding creative meetings until we finalized the designs. I highly recommend working with Takohl for anyone looking to create something custom that truly reflects their personal style. Tammy was professional, detail-oriented, and responsive, earning my trust throughout the entire process. I’m excited to partner with her on future projects and create more pieces together.

Aaron Hernandez When my fiancé asked if I wanted to do a wedding band workshop, I did not know what to expect! What an unforgettable experience! Janeane talked us through from start to finish, from planning to polishing! In a few short hours at the workshop we left with two unique, custom wedding rings!

Marylou Morin We had the BEST experience working with Susan! She helped us find our dream engagement ring and made the whole process feel so special and stress-free. She took the time to really listen to what we wanted, guided us with her expertise, and made sure every detail was perfect. On top of that, she also helped me create the perfect earring stack, and I’m absolutely obsessed with how it turned out. Susan is knowledgeable, kind, and truly amazing at what she does—we couldn’t be happier! Highly recommend!

Sabrina Holt Working with the Holzmanns to create our engagement ring was spectacular! We had a family stone we needed reset; they helped us design a setting, even providing a complimentary wax model to help me visualize the ring and make edits before it was cast. Their communication was great and they made an overwhelming experience feel easy.

Zakeer MS Awesome view and walk

Logan Sander I went to see Koorosh at Wedding Bands & Co for an engagement ring before a planned trip to St Lucia to propose to my girlfriend and I couldn’t be more pleased with my experience. Not only did Koorosh and his staff provide top notch service, but he personally designed exactly what I was looking for! My now fiancée was blown away by the ring as it was exactly what she had envisioned. I have always been used to traveling to New York for jewelry, but I am grateful to say that I no longer need to make that trip anymore. Moving forward, Koorosh and his location in Chicago will be my #1 go-to for any jewelry needs. Thank you Koorosh and Wedding Bands & Co!

Queen Me Loved my necklace at first. After a couple of months, I noticed every few days that the part of my necklace that rests on the back of my neck tarnishes so badly. It is unwearable after a week. I dont wear perfume or lotion. Maybe I got a defective one.

Mariyah Henley Maya Barr was a phenomenal consultant helping to navigate the ring purchasing process as a first time buyer. We visited the store in person and Maya worked with me for 3 months to perfect the ring in mind. I truly appreciated her guidance and help throughout the process! The final product was nothing short of amazing and I feel like I have the ring for a proposal that will be the beginning of forever. Thank you, Maya!

Daniel Vera Had such a great experience. I needed my sunglasses fixed and the owner went above and beyond to get them fixed. Will be back and soon !

Will Geiselhart I cannot speak highly enough of Bachrach Jewelers’ craftsmanship. I was introduced to Bachrach Jewelers by my father—when I was getting engaged, he told me Mark’s father had created my mother’s engagement and wedding rings and I reached out to Mark thinking the story couldn’t be better. Mark and his apprentice Elijah guided me through the process of selecting both the style of the ring and the stone—they do a tremendous job of making the jewelry-buying process accessible and comfortable. Mark always has a good story to share and his craftsmanship is unmatched. Mark created the most-complimented and gorgeous engagement ring I have ever seen and I have recommended their office to many of my friends. I have already returned to their shop for wedding bands and plan to do so again for custom jewelry down the road. It’s been a pleasure working with you, Mark and Eli!

Emily and Julian Rose, from Windy City Diamonds, did a fantastic job on both mine and my husbands wedding bands and my engagement ring. She was responsive, easy to work with, and fully understood and executed the vision making the rings stunningly beautiful and comfortable. They custom made both my engagement ring and wedding band and did the engraving for my husbands wedding band as well. I would absolutely recommend going here if you are shopping for rings because they can truly design it all and the process is effortless!

Sophia Loris Brilliant Earth sold my husband a wedding ring that was either broken upon arrival or had poor enough craftmanship that it broke within a month of our wedding. This followed an arduous process where the ring was remade twice and still did not fit. When asked for a resizing, they had the gall to request 600 dollars. Finally, to avoid the astronomical charges, we went to a local jeweler who informed us that the inlay gemstone was CRACKED down the middle! (Was it cracked during the constant and unsuccessful process of remaking it? I wonder.) They did offer to remake the ring for us, but we do not want to replace the ring which was an important part of our wedding less than a month ago for an exorbitant price. They did not offer either a repair or reimbursement for taking the ring to a qualified jeweler for repairs. Additionally, customer service was wonderful. Our saleswoman, Victoria, was clearly knowledgeable and eager to help us, but was just as clearly hamstrung by Brilliant Earths corporate process. Brilliant Earth specializes in wedding and engagement rings and the importance and sentimentality of such a purchase is in no way honored by their horrible quality assurance. To be blunt, it feels like their business model is to take advantage of the fact that these are one-time purchases, and that they do not have to be concerned about repeat customers. I truly hope that one day, leadership at this company can understand the pain they inflict on couples during an important moment in their lives.

Jack Power Stan and the team at M. Martin & Co are incredible. Stan helped find the perfect cut for my fiancé at a competitive price. Stan was patient and super knowledgeable about these gems. I have and will continue to recommend M. Martin & Co to friends and family. Thank you again for all the help!!

Brittany Boehm I cannot say enough great things about Gale Diamonds Chicago and my experience working with them! Mike designed both my engagement ring and wedding band, and his attention to detail and craftsmanship are truly exceptional. A few years after wearing my ring, I accidentally hit it against my work desk, causing the diamond to pop out. Mike not only reassured me that he could fix it but also went above and beyond by redesigning a more secure bar setting—while still maintaining the minimalist aesthetic I loved. His expertise and dedication to customer satisfaction are unmatched, and I couldn’t be happier with the final result. If you’re looking for a jeweler who genuinely cares about their work and clients, I highly recommend Gale Diamonds Chicago.